Yesterday, FBI agents raided the Los Angeles home of 27-year-old blogger Kevin Cogill and arrested him. Cogill's crime? He uploaded nine unreleased tracks from the upcoming Guns N' Roses album to his blog.
The album is titled "Chinese Democracy." Now there's an oxymoron for you.
Cogill admits to posting the files last June so GnR nuts could stream them off his music blog. He took them down when he received a cease and desist letter, and cooperated with the FBI in its investigation. According to Wikipedia (admittedly not the most reliable source) six of the songs had been made available in some other form and three were new.
Now Cogill's looking at three years in the pokey and fines of US$250,000, plus whatever damages the band might choose to pursue.
The legal argument here is that posting files for free kills legitimate sales of the music. (And Lord knows GnR must need the money -- they've only sold 90 million records during their career.) But Cogill didn't make the files available for downloading. He streamed them to a player on his blog.
If someone can explain to me how streaming music cuts out legitimate sales, I'd like to hear it. Don't we have an invention that does something very similar called ... radio? Hasn't that been the prime marketing vehicle for the recording industry for the past 50 years?
There's only one rational explanation for a deed so trivial to get this kind of attention. Someone with some serious juice is leaning on the feds.
Now I mean no disrepect to the hardworking guys and gals in blue suits and buzz cuts. They have a tough job and they seem to do it pretty well. In fact, the FBI has more on its plate than it can possibly handle. So to send five agents to arrest a scruffy blogger for streaming a handful of MP3s almost certainly means somebody pulled some strings.
Let me posit this hypothetical scenario. Recording industry mogul hears about the scruffy blogger, goes postal, calls his highly paid lobbying firm on K Street. Lobbyist contacts senator on the Judiciary Committee -- say, someone with a history of pushing RIAA-friendly legislation in return for major campaign donations (Orrin Hatch, your Blackberry is buzzing).
References
- He uploaded nine unreleased tracks from the upcoming Guns N' Roses album
- posting the files last June
- six of the songs had been made available in some other form
- whatever damages the band might choose to pursue
- Orrin Hatch, your Blackberry is buzzing
- a nice juicy story to run on how the Internet is destroying the recording industry
- far more serious breaches of the public trust
Latest on File Sharing & P2P
- Film industry sues iiNet over BitTorrent downloads
- ISP cut off from Internet after security concerns
- Apple response on Norwegian iTunes case fails to impress
- Harvard professor challenges RIAA anti-piracy campaign
- P2P legislation forcing university IT to get tough on piracy
- StartLinxter developing 'Internet service bus'
- RealDVDs, surreal lawsuits
- New industry group takes aim at 'net pollution,' piracy
- MySpace launches iTunes competitor with 5 million artists
- Vic police nab third player in national piracy syndicate
Software Essentials
- Ballmer: Yahoo acquisition won't happen
- Sun is a software company, new top shareholder says
- Forecast has Office, Vista going in opposite directions
- Interview with The Pirate Bay founder
- The future of software testing
- Bill Gates predicts software revolution
- 'Warez' software pirate sentenced to probation
- Mobile app development moves beyond CRM, but slowly
- Tibco backing Microsoft Silverlight
- Most top banks already using virtualization
TechWorld Jobs (beta)
Recent Jobs
TechWorld Blogs
-

TalkingTech
The view from the top of IT with TechWorld Editor Rodney Gedda
-

Entrenched
Cooking up better code, IDG's developers reveal some of their secrets
-

Broadband Voice
Darren Pauli digs in from the front line of Australia's broadband battleground
Recent blog posts
- An open storage stack? I like the sound of that
- The mobile clone wars: fighting for a better phone experience
- Stopping the "Clean Feed"
- Identifying web platforms
- Clean Feed ‘not technically possible’
- No Clean Feed - well duh!
- Conroy's content cops still on the cards
- Will open source ruin the economy? Please help
- Linux kernel 2.6.27 is out!
- Falling off the ob_start stack
Recent comments
- Hello this is Brianna
9 hours 39 min ago - Turn any PC into a media center
23 hours 31 min ago - How About the Correct Title?
1 day 14 hours ago - who are you kidding?
1 day 19 hours ago - Seriously, how much did they pay for this advertisement
3 days 10 hours ago - SF Bay Area - free Seminar on Enterprise Cloud Computing
3 days 13 hours ago - video conferening but not telepresence...
3 days 21 hours ago - SAMSUNG OLED 40" TECHNOLOGY
4 days 5 hours ago - What was the question again, oh well this was prepared earlier
6 days 12 hours ago - Worldwide broadband prices continue to drop which means ? in AU
6 days 13 hours ago - Not a Problem Here in Australia and New Zealand
1 week 1 day ago - Clear the air
1 week 2 days ago - Tabbed browsing, Quick Find,
1 week 5 days ago - Microsoft details plans for new social bookmarking tool
1 week 6 days ago - There is a 3rd party tool
2 weeks 1 day ago - Demise of Windows
2 weeks 1 day ago - new OS
2 weeks 1 day ago - Re: Favicon
2 weeks 2 days ago - Multi Camera Kino
2 weeks 2 days ago - Favicon
2 weeks 3 days ago



