G.ho.st, a startup that offers a hosted operating system, has accused Microsoft of violating a company trademark with its prominent use of the phrase "no walls" in its recently unveiled US$300 million Windows marketing and advertising campaign.
A letter from G.ho.st CEO Zvi Schreiber sent to Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer last Tuesday asked the company to stop using the phrases "life without walls," "imagine without walls" and "imagine no walls" on its products, Web site, marketing materials, advertising and other promotions and agree in writing to stop using these phrases by the close of business last Thursday.
As of Monday, Microsoft was still using the phrases in its campaign. Microsoft spokesman Michael Marinello said via e-mail Monday that the company acknowledged it had received Schreiber's letter but "the allegation is without merit."
Schreiber said G.ho.st has been using the phrase "no walls" to describe its G.ho.st Virtual Computer product, which is a hosted OS that runs in a virtual environment and is what he calls a "conceptual alternative to Windows," since April 2007.
Microsoft's use of "life without walls," "imagine without walls" and "imagine no walls" and their prominence on the marketing campaign "are virtually identical ... to our trademark," he wrote.
However, according to a record with the US Patent and Trademark Office, G.ho.st has not yet officially trademarked the phrase and only filed an application to do so last Tuesday, the day it sent Microsoft the letter.
Schreiber also suggested in the letter that Microsoft's use of the phrase "is designed to scare off potential investors in G.ho.st or partners of G.ho.st and prevent us from giving our innovative Virtual Computer solution a fair chance in the market place."
In addition to no longer using the phrase, G.ho.st also has requested that Microsoft publish "in the same media where these marks were displayed or advertised" clarification that it has not licensed G.ho.st's technology or trademark and that it doesn't offer the same "features or benefits of the G.ho.st Virtual Computer. "
Additionally, G.ho.st is asking Microsoft negotiate a "good faith" license for the past use of what the company believes is its trademark.
G.ho.st did not respond to a request for comment Monday about whether it would take legal action against Microsoft to resolve the matter. The company was founded in 2006 and has about 40 employees in Israel and the West Bank.
Latest on Windows Vista
- Microsoft e-mails detail internal fight on 'Vista Capable'
- Microsoft's 'Vista Capable' changes outraged HP, insider e-mails show
- Microsoft e-mails show 'Vista Capable' changes helped Intel
- If Windows is a dead end, what's next?
- Microsoft: Data shows Vista more secure than XP
- ActiveX bugs pose threat to Vista, Microsoft reports
- I'm a PC, she's a Mac. Are you a sucker?
- Ozzie points to slimmer future for Windows client
- Vista fights for relevancy against poor sales, XP, Windows 7
- Managing in mixed environments
TechWorld Jobs (beta)
Recent Jobs
TechWorld Blogs
-

TalkingTech
The view from the top of IT with TechWorld Editor Rodney Gedda
-

Entrenched
Cooking up better code, IDG's developers reveal some of their secrets
-

Broadband Voice
Darren Pauli digs in from the front line of Australia's broadband battleground
Recent blog posts
- An open storage stack? I like the sound of that
- The mobile clone wars: fighting for a better phone experience
- Stopping the "Clean Feed"
- Identifying web platforms
- Clean Feed ‘not technically possible’
- No Clean Feed - well duh!
- Conroy's content cops still on the cards
- Will open source ruin the economy? Please help
- Linux kernel 2.6.27 is out!
- Falling off the ob_start stack
Recent comments
- Hello this is Brianna
6 hours 46 min ago - Turn any PC into a media center
20 hours 37 min ago - How About the Correct Title?
1 day 11 hours ago - who are you kidding?
1 day 17 hours ago - Seriously, how much did they pay for this advertisement
3 days 7 hours ago - SF Bay Area - free Seminar on Enterprise Cloud Computing
3 days 10 hours ago - video conferening but not telepresence...
3 days 18 hours ago - SAMSUNG OLED 40" TECHNOLOGY
4 days 2 hours ago - What was the question again, oh well this was prepared earlier
6 days 9 hours ago - Worldwide broadband prices continue to drop which means ? in AU
6 days 10 hours ago - Not a Problem Here in Australia and New Zealand
1 week 1 day ago - Clear the air
1 week 2 days ago - Tabbed browsing, Quick Find,
1 week 5 days ago - Microsoft details plans for new social bookmarking tool
1 week 6 days ago - There is a 3rd party tool
2 weeks 1 day ago - Demise of Windows
2 weeks 1 day ago - new OS
2 weeks 1 day ago - Re: Favicon
2 weeks 2 days ago - Multi Camera Kino
2 weeks 2 days ago - Favicon
2 weeks 3 days ago




Comments
G.ho.st (http://G.ho.st) had prior rights to NO WALLS
In trademark law you accumulate rights by virtue of use - with or without registration. When G.ho.st applied for a registration recently, it was applying to register legal rights in the trademark NO WALLS which G.ho.st had already accumulated by public use of the trademark NO WALLS since April 2007, that is 17 months before Microsoft first used it.
Clearly Microsoft have no right to use the same trademark (or minor variations) as a much smaller direct competitor, and even though we are much smaller we are entitled to protect our intellectual property.
Zvi Schreiber, CEO, http://G.ho.st