Apple has asked a federal judge to dismiss a lawsuit brought by dissatisfied iPhone 3G owners because they did not ask the company to repair their iPhones or refund their money, according to court papers made public Friday.
In the motion, Apple's lawyers moved to dismiss the suit filed in August by an Alabama woman who said her iPhone 3G dropped calls, couldn't reliably connect to AT&T's network and was slower than advertised.
"The Defective iPhone 3G appeared to connect to the 3G standard and protocol less than 25 percent of the time," Jessica Smith's suit said. "Additionally, Plaintiff experienced an inordinate amount of dropped calls." Smith was later joined by another iPhone owner, Wilton Triggs, in the lawsuit, which has also sought class-action status.
iPhone users began complaining about making calls and keeping a connection within days of the smart phone's July 11 debut. Since then, Apple has released a pair of iPhone software updates, including one in September that seemed to solve network problems for some users.
On Friday, however, Apple said the lawsuit should be tossed out.
"Plaintiffs' Amended Complaint conspicuously omits one critical condition precedent to all three causes of action: an allegation that they contacted Apple to seek a repair of the alleged defects or a replacement iPhone 3G under Apple's One (1) Year Limited Warranty," Apple's attorneys argued.
By Alabama law, as well as the terms of Apple's warranty, consumers are required to ask for repair or a replacement, or a refund, before filing a lawsuit, Apple said. "Plaintiffs do not allege that they notified Apple of the alleged problems they experienced, or otherwise attempted to obtain a repair or replacement under warranty," the motion continued. "Instead, Plaintiffs allege that Apple is generally 'aware of the above-stated defects' and has 'attempted to undertake corrective action too late with little or no success'."
Apple's motion for dismissal cited sections of the Alabama Commercial Code, Apple's own warranty and other legal precedents in moving that the judge make Smith's lawsuit moot.
Two weeks after Smith sued Apple, a New Jersey man filed a separate lawsuit in federal court. Like Smith, Eulardi Tanseco said his iPhone dropped calls and wouldn't consistently connect with AT&T's network.
Apple has not filed a response to those charges.
Latest on Apple
- Apple wins antitrust fight with Psystar, judge tosses claims
- Google launches iPhone voice search app
- Why developers prefer Macs
- Apple plays catch-up, adds anti-fraud safeguard to Safari
- How 10 Famous Technology Products Got Their Names
- Parallels speeds up Windows on Macs with latest upgrade
- Apple to weather spending breakdown better than rivals?
- Letting Apple into the enterprise isn't easy
- MacBook Pro is built to last
- MobileMe stumbles again, goes dark for nearly 7 hours
Hardware Essentials
- Chip shipments could face slow growth
- Gartner to slash 2009 chip forecast by $25 billion
- Researchers find state of matter that may extend Moore's Law
- Forgotten history: the true origins of the PC
- Researchers develop bug-blocking chip monitor
- Intel, AMD multicore chip sales may be slowed by software
- Asustek turns to Celerons amid Atom shortage
- Strong Intel sales push global PC chip market to record Q2
- Via pushing into laptop, desktop markets with 5 new chips
- Xerox showcases erasable paper, smart documents
TechWorld Jobs (beta)
Recent Jobs
TechWorld Blogs
-

TalkingTech
The view from the top of IT with TechWorld Editor Rodney Gedda
-

Entrenched
Cooking up better code, IDG's developers reveal some of their secrets
-

Broadband Voice
Darren Pauli digs in from the front line of Australia's broadband battleground
Recent blog posts
- A Novell approach to business
- An open storage stack? I like the sound of that
- The mobile clone wars: fighting for a better phone experience
- Stopping the "Clean Feed"
- Identifying web platforms
- Clean Feed ‘not technically possible’
- No Clean Feed - well duh!
- Conroy's content cops still on the cards
- Will open source ruin the economy? Please help
- Linux kernel 2.6.27 is out!
Recent comments
- Hello this is Brianna
23 hours 17 min ago - Turn any PC into a media center
1 day 13 hours ago - How About the Correct Title?
2 days 4 hours ago - who are you kidding?
2 days 9 hours ago - Seriously, how much did they pay for this advertisement
4 days 12 min ago - SF Bay Area - free Seminar on Enterprise Cloud Computing
4 days 3 hours ago - video conferening but not telepresence...
4 days 10 hours ago - SAMSUNG OLED 40" TECHNOLOGY
4 days 19 hours ago - What was the question again, oh well this was prepared earlier
1 week 2 hours ago - Worldwide broadband prices continue to drop which means ? in AU
1 week 2 hours ago - Not a Problem Here in Australia and New Zealand
1 week 2 days ago - Clear the air
1 week 3 days ago - Tabbed browsing, Quick Find,
1 week 5 days ago - Microsoft details plans for new social bookmarking tool
2 weeks 1 hour ago - There is a 3rd party tool
2 weeks 1 day ago - Demise of Windows
2 weeks 1 day ago - new OS
2 weeks 2 days ago - Re: Favicon
2 weeks 3 days ago - Multi Camera Kino
2 weeks 3 days ago - Favicon
2 weeks 4 days ago



