Ubuntu Studio says no to Unity, adopts Xfce
- 16 May, 2011 11:29
- Comments 1
An example Xfce 4.8 desktop environment
In another sign Canonical’s Unity desktop environment is not resonating well with the wider Ubuntu community, multimedia-centric Ubuntu derivative, Ubuntu Studio, will move from the GNOME to the Xfce desktop for its next release.
Last month Ubuntu Studio celebrated the 11.04 ‘Natty Narwhal’ release with the rest of the Ubuntu community, but unlike the main Ubuntu release did not turn on the Unity desktop and instead opted to keep GNOME as the default interface.
“Ubuntu Studio does not currently use Unity. As the user logs in it will default to Gnome Classic Desktop (i.e. Gnome2),” according the Ubuntu Studio 11.04 release notes.
Read the rest of the 11.04 release notes here: Ubuntu Studio 11.04 ‘Natty Narwhal’ release notes.
However, just this weekend, the Ubuntu Studio project went one step further and announced it was moving away from Unity and GNOME to the open source Xfce desktop as the default environment.
Ubuntu Studio developer Scott Lavender wrote on his blog the project will be moving to Xfce, a desktop environment promoted as being “lightweight and fast”.
Lavender wrote Ubuntu’s decision to go with Unity raised concerns regarding how the new desktop would “affect the typical Ubuntu Studio user’s work flow”.
“The consensus within the team is that Unity was not an optimal choice for Ubuntu Studio at this time,” according to Lavender.
The Studio developers considered using the ‘classic’ GNOME desktop, but since it won’t be shipped with the next Ubuntu release — 11.10 ‘Oneiric Ocelot’ — they concluded questions remain around the ongoing support of GNOME packages, particularly gnome-panel, by Canonical.
“Therefore, it quickly became evident that staying with GNOME panel as our default DE did not represent a viable choice for project sustainability,” Lavender wrote.
The Studio developers believe Xfce has advantages over GNOME, KDE and Unity because it provides a “familiar desktop metaphor” and is a more “resource friendly environment”.
Xfce and GNOME both use the GTK+ libraries to develop their graphical interfaces. But with the release of GNOME 3 last month, the GNOME Shell UI is taking the project in a new direction on the desktop.
While pushing the innovation bar for a free desktop, both Ubuntu’s Unity and GNOME 3 have attracted criticism for being too radical a departure from their GNOME 2 tradition on the desktop. A few years ago KDE’s move version 4 attracted the same kind of criticism.
The Ubuntu Studio developers will also use the move to Xfce as an opportunity to explore updating the distribution’s user interface.
The Xfce project is online at: http://www.xfce.org/.
Follow Rodney Gedda on Twitter: @rodneygedda
Follow TechWorld Australia on Twitter: @Techworld_AU
- Bookmark this page
- Share this article
- Got more on this story? Email TechWorld
- Follow TechWorld on twitter
- Ubuntu Natty released, Unity for desktops and netbooks
- Ubuntu Studio 11.04 ‘Natty Narwhal’ release notes
- Scott Lavender’s blog
- Work begins on Ubuntu 11.10 'Oneiric Ocelot'
- Ubuntu's marketing kick: Is Canonical the next Apple?
- GNOME 3 is out: will Ubuntu reconsider?
- The Xfce project
- Twitter: @rodneygedda
- Twitter: @Techworld_AU
- Top 5 Myths of Safe Web Browsing
- Virtual Certainty - Best Practices for Gaining Monitoring Clarity in VMware Environments
- EMC 15-Minute Guide to Smarter Backup Transform your future
- Five Things You Need to Know About Your Users Before You Deploy Business Intelligence
- Key Considerations in Modernising Your Backup and Deduplication Solutions
-
Broadband Forum to improve IPTV performance with new spec
-
Amazon Web Services moves backups to cloud with new appliance
-
Callforfree.net.au offers free calls to 70 countries
-
Intel ponders solar-powered CPU tech in graphics, memory
-
Apple files complaint against Chinese vendor for using EPAD trademark
-
MYOB Software for Dummies 6E Australian Edition
-
Microsoft Office
-
Computers for Seniors for Dummies, 2nd Edition
-
Office 2007 for Dummies
-
Windows 7 for Dummies® Dvd+book Bundle
-
Teach Yourself Visually Windows 7
-
Excel 2007 All-In-One Desk Reference for Dummies
-
Office 2007 All-In-One Desk Reference for Dummies
-
Windows 7 for Dummies®
Comments
dave
I think the saddest part of the entire thing is how the community has been ignored, in the entire fiasco. When Gnome 3 was released.. most of us groaned. Sure, there are some happy users.. but a lot of those people are those who seem unable to customize/modify their own desktops, in the first place. It's one thing to be lazily content with what is farted in our general direction, but some of us are clearly feeling antagonized by the new trend of destroying customization. Try to make Unity or Gnome 3 look unique - It's nearly impossible.. by design.
.. I won't even get started on what bothers me about Unity, in particular.. but the whole Gnome vs Unity vs Everything Else-thing is not good for the state of Linux-user-confusion. The fragmentation of the distributions is confusing enough, for newcomers, but the landscape of desktop environments, compounded by the interchangeable window managers / decorators / other pieces of the puzzle, has remained a huge turn-off. Unity should have sought to bring people together under an umbrella of simplicity, but it has divided us even farther apart.. to the point that I truly wonder what will become of Gnome and Canonical.
Too much political posturing has been applied to this junk, yknow? It's like they're not allowed to admit that the desktop environments they're pushing, are not as good as they at first thought. Not being able to admit fault is a political feature that has no place in the open source arena.
I often wonder how much of this was predicted, prior to the release of Gnome 3. Xfce seemed to balloon to the size of Gnome 2, immediately prior to Gnome 2's discontinuation. Similar timing for LXDE usurping Xfce's position as "the lightweight DE" ..
..the whole thing is very fishy.. somewhat big business-feeling, to me.
Post new comment