Techworld

Bodhi Linux review

Taking the Enlightenment-based Bodhi Linux for a test drive

It seems that as yet there is no agreed upon acronym for Ubuntu-based Linux distributions — Yet Another Ubuntu Derivative (YAUD), perhaps?* Along with the 'regular' Ubuntu-derived distros — Kubuntu and Xubuntu, for example — you can get all manner of niche distros (Satanic Edition, anyone?)

Bodhi Linux, version 1.0 of which was released in late March, is somewhat different to most YUADs: It uses Enlightenment 17 to provide a desktop environment.

The distribution also has a philosophy at odds with many desktop-focussed distros. It provides a minimalist installation that will appeal to people who like to endlessly tinker with their desktop setups. The creators state that they believe in "User Choice, so we don't give you three pre-installed mail clients to choose from. It does not mean that there is every browser possible at the click of a button.

"What it does mean is that we have our own repositories and these are accessible via the apt-get command line, GUI package manager or better still our on line software store."

In that sense it's comparable to something like CrunchBang Linux: It can keep out of your way and let you get on with tweaking everything to your liking. But, unlike CrunchBang, Bodhi runs Enlightenment. And Enlightenment offers an enticing combination: It's designed to be lightweight yet still appeal to all those who can't live without an eye-candy-filled desktop.

As is common with most Linux distros, you can burn the ISO to CD or copy to a USB drive using a program like UNetbootin, then boot into a desktop environment. From here you can install it to the hard drive of your notebook or desktop PC. We tested Bodhi with both a Lenovo S10 netbook and a Dell Optiplex GX620 PC.

Installation on both was straightforward, though initially at least the S10's touchpad wouldn't work (it worked during a second installation, however; this problem hasn't been encountered in the past, but may be a hardware issue). After installing and rebooting the OS it seemed fine. During your initial log-in you are able to select a profile — Bare, Desktop, Ecomorph, Fancy, Laptop or Tablet/Netbook — and then a theme.

On the S10, we were underwhelmed by the default interface, despite selecting the Tablet/Netbook option. It felt too crowded by default, especially in comparison to CrunchBang or Peppermint Ice, both of which are distros we recommend looking at if you're interested in a netbook-friendly operating system. We also encountered hangs on shutdown, and errors when logging in again on boot. Installation also took significantly longer than some of the lightweight distributions installed on the S10 in the past.

On the Dell desktop it was a different experience, and the default setup was far more appealing. The Enlightenment interface takes some getting used to if you're more familiar with GNOME or other desktop environments. Jeff Hoogland, Bodhi's lead developer, has a useful blog entry with some tips for getting started with Enlightenment. Naturally Bodhi Linux's website includes a lot of helpful documentation, too

Only a minimum of applications are installed. The lightweight Leafpad text editor is installed instead of an office suite, and by default you get the Midori Web browser instead of Firefox or Chrome. I have come to appreciate this approach a lot more than distros that throw in three of every kind of program you might want to run. Why bother when almost anything you could possibly want is just an apt-get install away?

Errors are to be expected, given Enlightenment's ongoing development, and I encountered a number of them. I found myself, for example, having to close about a dozen dialogue boxes when the Dell PC started up. There are also quirks, such as submenus of menus up against the side of the desktop opening outside the desktop area (so you can't make a selection).

But despite this, and despite the (shallow) learning curve, it's clear that Enlightenment has a lot to offer people who are after a desktop experience that is both rich and customisable. It comes with a range of desktop Gadgets, and there is a lot of scope to set your environment up so it's Just Right. Gadgets include a Mac-esque launcher at the bottom of the screen, a container object for icons, a virtual desktop pager, clocks, calendars and a CPU usage monitor.

Special mention must be made of Run Everything: An extremely powerful and customisable launcher. At a basic level it provides quick access to your documents and installed applications. However, it is capable of much, much more; check out the Bodhi Linux wiki entry for more information.

In the end we were somewhat underwhelmed by the end user experience though. Bodhi can be very pretty to look at, and you can make it even prettier if you take the time, but these days I find myself longing for super-minimalist desktops with a focus on staying out of the way (of course, Bodhi can be made to be this as well, if you are interested in learning the ins and outs of Enlightenment). The simplicity of the default installation is great — I don't like being overloaded with apps. But there was just not enough there to hold my interest — I'd rather install CrunchBang and customise Openbox.

On the flipside: If you want to play with Enlightenment (and who doesn't like playing with new desktop environments) then by all means check it out. The Bodhi team has done a great job of creating a relatively friendly vehicle for playing with Enlightenment — it's just not for me.

There is a new version of Bodhi Linux out: Version 1.1.0. Hopefully this will have addressed some of the quirks we encountered.

*(Or should that be I Can't Believe It's Not Debian — ICBIND?)

Follow Rohan Pearce on Twitter: @rohan_p

Follow Techworld Australia on Twitter: @techworld_au

Join the TechWorld newsletter!

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags Linuxopen sourceubuntu

More about DebianDellDell ComputerISOLenovoLinuxUbuntu

8 Comments

Jeff Hoogland

1

Thanks for the write up! Just a couple of comments -

First, you mentioned the interface was cluttered on one system and nice on the other. People reading this that don't use Enlightenment won't know that you choose how cluttered you want your layout to be. Selecting the "desktop" profile gives the user a layout as simple as PepperMint (which you mentioned). The "cluttered" profile you selected is geared towards the classic netbook/launcher interfaces you see on many systems. Some users like these.

And the slew of messages on startup is from upgrading your packages from 1.0.0 to the latest 1.1.0 version. They happen once and then never occur again (a result of E's heavy development)

Guest

2

Hey give Pinguy OS Mini a try as well.

Jani

3

I think "Yet Another Ubuntu Derivative" shortens to YAUD, not YUAD.

Ro3b

4

Transmission don´t work while instalation.

ylee

5

Bodhi is a great distro and enlightenment is relatively easy to learn to use if you actually give it a try. The Bodhi documentation team has been working pretty hard lately trying to write a beginners guide to enlightenment that is easy for e17 newbies to follow yet fairly comprehensive within reason. Guides to enlightenment found online seem to be lacking and relatively far and few between. It is a work in progress and can be found on Bodhi' wiki and nearly all of it is applicable to any enlightenment based distro. As to the menu quirk mentioned here, that is not really a quirk as much as a design decision of the e17 devs. All one has to do is mouse over to the hidden sub menu items and the menu moves to display them ;)

Roger

6

I've installed Bodhi on my Atom N270, 160 Gb, 1 Gb RAM, 2 years old 10'' netbook, and I'm a convert!
I have tried every distro in search of of a lightweight, yet beautiful interface, lubuntu being my closest call until Bodhi.
Enlightenment is easy to learn and the reward is eye candy and practicality AND an old computer turned fast. Plus, I can install any Ubuntu app.
One should definitely give it a try!

Ian Mowbray

7

Easy to install and easy to install any software you want. Definitely a snappy feel to it. The desktop themes are pretty, not that it's essential, and things are well laid out. It took a little playing to see how enlightenment worked, but I was looking for something as an alternative to Gnome3 and Unity, both of which I tried and ended up hating. The Bodhi site and its docs are really excellent. My alternative was/is Xfce, which I also like very much, and have on another laptop. However, this is now the laptop I grab because it's fun, pretty, and efficient to use.

David Gurvich

8

I've installed Bodhi 1.2 on a netbook and an older Thinkpad. The only issue I've had is with upgrading and restarting E17. Many modules don't upgrade gracefully and crash E17. I would suggest doing a full reboot between upgrades.

On both systems ecore was kept back which caused a problem with the modules. The reponsive is excellent and everything except Banshee works well. Banshee requires a newer version to work properly with ipods.

Comments are now closed

Top Whitepapers

Twitter Feed

Featured Whitepapers