NBN decision: better broadband or bigger bureaucracy?
So the federal government has thrown down the gauntlet and decided to go ahead and lead from the front to create the National Broadband Network with the help of private industry. Amid all the commotion about Telstra's omission from the original proposal, a new government department to build and manage the NBN appears decidedly ironic. Telstra was Australia's national phone and data services company, the industry was deregulated with the aim of introducing more competition, Telstra inherited all the taxpayer-funded infrastructure, deregulation failed to deliver a high-speed national network, ADSL deployments were hampered by access restrictions and Telstra's unwillingness to cannibalise existing cable investments, and now the government wants to start again under the guise of another national infrastructure business. Talk about deja vu.
The $43 billion question is, of course, will the government get it right this time or are we in for more bungling bureaucracy?
Given the ongoing post-deregulation climate surrounding Telstra and its reluctance to co-operate with the other carriers, the government's NBN decision does seem like a “good” one (anything, and I mean anything that promotes more competition in the data networking space is good), but it also begs the question of why this couldn't have happened within the auspices of the government-owned Telstra of 10 years ago.
It's not an easy question to answer, but a good place to start would be to examine how deregulation happened, not why.
Deregulation promotes competition, however, there will only be full competition if the basic building block is available to all commercial entities equally.
Instead, the modern Telstra wholesale and retail businesses just inherited all the public communications infrastructure under the guise of “deregulation”.
A far more open approach would have been to keep all the public assets – the exchanges, the cabling, etc – in government hands (call it a separate government business if you will, how about ATIC – Australian Telecommunications Infrastructure Corporation?), and allow all carriers – including Telstra – to lease access it at wholesale rates.
The retail arms of the carriers then go ahead and sell it to consumers in the form of telephone and Internet access services, and ATIC as a wholesaler only has no retail presence and therefore no conflict of interest – unlike our friend the Big T!
The revenue raised through selling access then gets ploughed back into maintaining and upgrading the network – no questions asked about “access permissions”.
With this architecture, the existing national infrastructure just becomes the NBN, and there's no need to re-create a special “NBN” in parallel.
Today's announcement seems remarkably similar to what might have been if deregulation prevented the infrastructure from falling into Telstra's lap the way it did.
Only time will tell if Rudd and Conroy's nation building exercise will reap the broadband services Australian consumers and businesses so desperately require. Broadband or no broadband, one thing's for sure – there will me more bureaucracy.
BIG-IQ Security makes it easy to manage the entire firewall policy life cycle. Read about the key benefits and download the policy auditing and security compliance report today
This whitepaper discusses why the periodic refresh of an organisation’s PCs and devices makes sense from both IT and business perspectives, to maintain productivity and top-notch security. • As PCs age, the systems start to incur high maintenance costs and expose organizations to heightened security risks • There is a need to carefully match client computers to the requirements of the workforce • With the right combination of hardware, software and services, organisations can maximize the benefits of a client refresh while driving down cost and complexity
- IEEE standards group wants to bring order to IoT
- InfiniDB going out of business, but its database will live on as open source
- FCC questions how to enforce net neutrality rules
- iPhone 6 review roundup -- the raves come quietly
- Alibaba shares open at a high $92.70
- New organization sets out to make secure communication tools more user-friendly
- Tim Cook launches iPhone 6 sales in Palo Alto
- HP leapfrogs Red Hat to become top contributor to OpenStack
- New iPhone 6 and 6 Plus are easier to repair
- Shut out on iPhone 6 Plus, buyers settle for smaller version
- Screen size matters to Apple fans in line for the iPhone 6
- Half-baked mergers
- Ping Identity picks up $35 million more in venture funding
- Apple's iOS 8 fixes enterprise Wi-Fi authentication hijacking issue
- Watch video of the first iPhone 6...being dropped