Is Network Co. the way to go?
Probably the most interesting thing to come out of Malcolm Turnbull’s speech at the National Press Club yesterday was the idea that the coalition, given the opportunity, would separate Telstra and transfer the wholesale assets to a new “Network Co”. At TechWorld we posed a similar idea, but we can’t help but ask, is it workable?
First let’s consider how such an idea could come about to begin with.
If telecommunications was ever going to be meaningful in the country then it would most certainly have to involve the absolution of any potential conflict between the network operator and service retails for most of the last-mile residential network.
As it happened, the Australian taxpayer built up a national telecommunications provider in Telstra (then also known as Telecom) which provided retail fixed line and mobile telecommunications services while maintaining control of the majority of the backhaul infrastructure.
When deregulation went ahead in the nineties Telstra wasn’t structurally separated and the only real difference made was competitive players could offer fixed line services off Telstra’s network. So the level of competition was only ever going to be as good as Telstra would allow it.
Fast forward to today and the federal government is full steam ahead building a national communications monopoly to rival Telstra in the form of NBN Co. So at a fundamental level there is little difference between an independent Telstra Wholesale and the new NBN.
Is there a half-way house? Well, yes, there is. The mandated structural separation of Telstra and another government-owned wholesaler created out of the ruins is that half-way house.
Turnbull calls it “Network Co”, but at TechWorld we dubbed it ATIC – Australian Telecommunications Infrastructure Corporation – more than two years ago.
Consider it this way:
- Telstra’s wholesale assets get transferred to “Network Co.” or “ATIC”.
- The new wholesale-only provider’s network progressively gets upgraded to FttP
- The existing management systems of Telstra wholesale are leveraged
- The bureaucratic overhead of a new NBN Co is eliminated in favour of a re-branded “Network Co” or “ATIC”
So on paper it looks reasonable enough. The big question is whether it could ever work in practice. Could Telstra ever be separated to an extent which rivals the independence of the new NBN Co? Given that Telstra’s copper network is scheduled to be replaced by NBN Co’s fibre then the answer to that question looks like being an inevitable yes.
Telstra will eventually have to come to terms with its wholesale monopoly position being eroded.
However, as Turnbull said, Telstra is encumbered by its wholesale infrastructure legacy right now. I’m just not convinced the modern – and quite diverse – Telstra retail service provider won’t be able to compete with alternative providers without owning all the network. Just this week news surfaced that Vodafone is losing thousands of customers – perhaps mostly to Telstra – to rival mobile service providers.
If Telstra was treated “like another customer” for wholesale access, do you really think its marketing machine and customer service operations would be put at an inherent disadvantage?
We’ll have to await the outcome of the next federal election to see whether “Network Co” becomes a reality. Until then, lovers of very fast broadband will yearn for the day NBN Co fibre passes their front door. They have until November 30, 2013 at the latest until the guarantee gets jeopardised.
Follow Rodney Gedda on Twitter: @rodneygedda
Follow TechWorld Australia on Twitter: @Techworld_AU
Flash storage represents a quantum leap from the storage layer in terms of performance, however it is crucial companies understand their I/O profile in order to formulate a successful storage strategy. Find out in this eBook how flash storage can be beneficial for enterprises and useful questions to ask before making an informed decision on the purchase.
- CCInformation ArchitectQLD
- CCAEM DeveloperNSW
- CCJava Development Contract - MelbourneVIC
- FTSenior .NET DeveloperVIC
- CCSenior Server EngineerNSW
- CCOracle Test LeadNSW
- CCWindows System Admin, Administrator, Technical SupportNSW
- CCContract Analyst Programmer (Crystal Reports) 160129/AP/vhs-aAsia
- CCSenior Test AnalystSA
- CCEnterprise Architect - Network & InfrastructureNSW
- FTSenior Linux Sys AdminNSW
- CCJava Development EngineerNSW
- FTApplication Support AnalystVIC
- CCContract System Engineer (Lotus Domin) 160129/SE/vccAsia
- CCContract Programmer (Crystal Reports/JAVA/SQL) 160129/P/vhs-cAsia
- CCOracle Developer - 3 month contractSA
- FTNetwork Systems LeadVIC
- FTLinux AdministratorVIC
- FTDatabase AdministratorVIC
- CCFront End Developer - MelbourneVIC
- CCUX DesignerNSW
- CCTechnical Tester - AutomationVIC
- CCHelpdesk SupportNSW
- FTProject Manager | SharePoint, Office 365 SkillsVIC
This eBook provides a broad overview of micro-segmentation in the data centre. After reading this , you’ll have a good basic understanding of micro-segmentation — like you’d get from a college-level 101 class, but far more interesting than Microbiology 101 or Microeconomics 101 (and not as difficult either)!
- Schneier: terrorists will switch to more secure alternatives to avoid encryption backdoors
- Indegy finds out when industrial controls go bad (think Stuxnet)
- Critical VPN key exchange flaw exposes Cisco security appliances to remote hacking
- Qualcomm bringing LTE connectivity to wearables with new Wear platform
- Qualcomm's new chips target low-cost smartphones with premium features
- House bill would prevent patchwork of state laws banning smartphone encryption
- Facebook withdraws Free Basics from India after regulatory debacle
- Stock-market jitters have rocked network spending, Cisco says
- SD-WAN: What it is and why you’ll use it one day
- Android root malware widespread in third-party app stores
- UCLA just open-sourced a powerful new image-detection algorithm
- SCO vs. IBM legal battle over Linux may – finally – be finished
- Microsoft adds conservative release 'ring' to Windows 10 beta program
- 6 things you should know about Twitter's timeline change
- Microsoft lets cautious users try more of Windows 10’s leading edge