Sunday 23 November, 2008
Desktop Linux face-off: Ubuntu 8.04 vs. Fedora 9
The recent releases of Ubuntu 8.04 and Fedora 9 mark another step forward in the evolution of the Linux desktop
Robert Strohmeyer (PC World) 03/06/2008 11:03:06

By default, Fedora includes SELinux, which enforces security policies throughout the OS. Developed by the U.S. National Security Agency, this app does an excellent job of alerting users to potential security threats and managing user authentication. Most users will find that the biggest benefit of SELinux is its management of root user authority: The program alerts you when you've had root privileges activated for more than a few minutes, so you can minimize your exposure from this vulnerability.

For users who are already familiar with Linux, Fedora 9 is an excellent choice. Robust security features and installation options make it somewhat more versatile than Ubuntu, which offers a more streamlined (and therefore more restricted) installation. For most users, though, including millions interested in trying Linux for the first time, Fedora lacks the polish and ready-to-run simplicity of its more popular rival.

Ubuntu 8.0.4 offers a level of functionality comparable to that of Mac OS and Windows, from delivery to installation to daily use. Unfortunately, the ties that bind all Linux distributions — primarily a lack of support for major Windows- and Mac-based business, design, and gaming applications — still hold Ubuntu back from mass popularity. For users with such moderate computing needs as Web browsing, e-mail, and basic document creation, however, Hardy is a compelling option.

Comments

Ubuntu -v- Fedora?

I have actually dual-booted this PC with Fedora 8 and Ubuntu 8.04. Given a choice, I generally boot the Ubuntu installation, because of it's relative simplicity in carrying out some things. Having said that, my perception of both installations was that they are both very simple.

I remember the first Linux installation I ever did : RedHat 5.2 if I recall correctly. It wasn't as bad as the average Debian install (I still don't get that one!) but now, I feel any distro is relatively simple to install, if there are no "odd hardware" issues.

Getting the programs you want is also relatively simple if you have any sort of a broadband connection, you let the graphical "Add/Remove Software" program find it, resolve any dependencies, and install for you.

Last, but not least, the author made no mention of Wine. If you absolutely must run Windows programs, there is a good chance they'll run under Linux using Wine!

The Linux Evolution/Revolution

The operating system is not the end game but an enabler for greater things. It's good to see usable desktops emerging from the Linux community. Not only is this interesting for conventional desktops and laptops but offers opportunities in the virtualised world where licensing costs can be a show stopper.

Market Place
 

Techworld Australia Member Login

c